VWBB - About the Marines in Babylon 5

Show all 20 posts from this thread on one page

VWBB (https://volitionwatch.game-warden.com/vwbb/index.php)
- The Babylon Project (https://volitionwatch.game-warden.com/vwbb/forumdisplay.php?forumid=16)
-- About the Marines in Babylon 5 (https://volitionwatch.game-warden.com/vwbb/showthread.php?threadid=4712)

Posted by mobvekhar on 11-21-2001 05:52 PM:

About the Marines in Babylon 5

Do you think the Marines of the EA would have there own fightersquadrons? like the American Marines have today?

__________________
"Collision Alert, Collision Alert"

Posted by Phantom on 11-21-2001 06:15 PM:

I'm not sure. Garibaldi can fly a Starfury and he was a gropo.
I don't think that would be something they would teach you
as a chief of security.

Posted by Wildlife on 11-21-2001 06:20 PM:

hmm, i dunno
zack could fly star-fury too so maybe

__________________
1. Liverpool FC ARE going to win the champions league. next season!
2.The world without me is like a blunt pencil.......
Pointless :)
Did you hear? England 5 - Germany 1!!!!!!
Did You See? England 1 - Argentinia 0!!!!!

Posted by FSF Ashrak on 11-21-2001 06:22 PM:

DON'T CARE DON'T CARE

__________________
[URL=http://www.hot.ee/ashrak]Ashrak and Miburos Render Lair[/URL]

WEBSITE NOW UP AND RUNNING!!!!!

Posted by Raider on 11-21-2001 08:02 PM:

No, they have their breaching pods.
This is enough, for the space superority (stupid spelling)
is the rest of the Earthforce there.

Posted by Coal on 11-21-2001 10:58 PM:

For space, fighter support would prolly be given by the navy.

In an atmosphere, they would prolly have their own air support. One of the reasons (if I've learned correctly) that US Marines have their own air groups is that because, when a navy or air force pilot is supporting them, they're supporting Marines. When a Marine pilot is doing it, they're supporting their buddies. Marine pilots go through the same training (or at least some of it) that regular marine grunts go through, so the pilots have an understanding of what the grunts will need.

It also means that the Marines have dedicated air support that can be called directly, instead of going through the other services channels.

But I ain't a Marine, so I don't know fully if that's how it goes. From my understanding form TV and books, that's one of the reasons.

__________________
This is it. That moment they told us about in high school, where one day, algebra would save our lives.

Rules of life:
1) Never eat anything bigger than your head.
2) Never play pool at a place called 'Pops'.
3) Never eat at a place called 'Moms'.

Posted by Traps59 on 11-21-2001 11:45 PM:

...

Something like Space: Above and Beyond? all marines in that show double as space pilots.

__________________
"There it is, the exact genetic code for my ideal woman."

Posted by Coal on 11-22-2001 12:27 AM:

quote:
Something like Space: Above and Beyond? all marines in that show double as space pilots.

You mean the pilots getting training as grunts? No, that ain't done in real life. A pilot's a pilot and a grunt's a grunt. They don't do both.

I think that part of S:AAB was one of the things that ruined an otherwise great show.

Posted by Ghost Rider on 11-22-2001 05:25 AM:

To be completely honest B5 wasn't exactly the most realistic portrayal of military accuracy for certain subjects. A lot of that can be seen in how they handled fighters, practically everyone but the damn doctor knew how to fly Furies or could be taught to fly T-Bolts. In B5 pretty much everyone started out in fighters then moved up, it was ridiculous that people like Garibaldi and Zack could fly Furies, they aren't even officers only enlistedmen, enlisted personnel don't fly anything but can be part of flight crews in most branches of the US military, only the Army has pilots who aren't officers called Warrant Officers (my dad is one) and though Garibaldi was Chief Warrant Officer his duties have absolutely nothing to do with fighters, then again neither does Sheridan or Ivanova for that matter.

Pilots in the Navy usually move on to avaition oriented positions such as becoming a CAG (Commander Air Group) and as I understand it because of the duties aboard an Aircraft Carrier and the experience learned being a pilot often Carrier captains were pilots. But Sheridan who was in a Cruiser or Lochley in a Destroyer have no business knowing how to fly fighters (realistically). Only Sinclair could be believable as a fighter pilot because that was what he was introduced as, a wing commander during the EA-Minbari War. Then maybe he transferred out of active flight status after the Line.

I think it'd be great if there were Marine fighter pilots in B5 (I want to be a Marine pilot myself) but I doubt B5 has them, then again the workings of Earth Force aren't exactly clear, Naval personnel are promoted from Captain to General instead of Admiral, that's really wrong. But being a tv show I leave it to artistic license and suspension of disbelief as an excuse.

__________________
One last stand to hold the line against the night...EA President

Posted by Londo Molari on 11-22-2001 06:29 AM:

When it comes to the EA, the starfury is a lot more than a space fighter, its also a rescue ship, scout ship, and other stuff

And living on Babylon 5, you HAVE to be able to handle a fighter, its the primary defence. So they give basic training to all officers.

The role of a starfury isnt like that of an F/A-18 now-a-days

thats why B5 depiction is pretty accurate.

__________________
I have carefully selected the following words of wisdom for my signature:
"Gravity, you win again." - Zap Brannigan.
"Real men over-clock their modems!" - Vertigo.
"Death to SIERRA/TNT/XOOM/Fortunecity" - Me.

Posted by Ghost Rider on 11-22-2001 10:16 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by Londo Molari
When it comes to the EA, the starfury is a lot more than a space fighter, its also a rescue ship, scout ship, and other stuff

And living on Babylon 5, you HAVE to be able to handle a fighter, its the primary defence. So they give basic training to all officers.

The role of a starfury isnt like that of an F/A-18 now-a-days

thats why B5 depiction is pretty accurate.

Though I won't enter into a debate about it, I disagree. The Star Fury is an interceptor by definition since it doesn't have the strike capabilities of the T-Bolt and possibly Badger (though its role has never been clearly defined either other than heavy fighter). The Fury is not a rescue ship in its role, it has grappling hooks that can be used for that but it's not one of its designed duties. Scout or recon is also something todays fighters do so thay still falls under the role of the fighter pilot.

It wasn't just the people on Babylon 5, every Earth Force member could fly a frickin' Star Fury. And no matter where they live or what they have as a defense, in reality fighter pilot roles would just be handled by that, fighter pilots. It's what they are specifically trained for. Training everyone to fly fighters is like training everyone in the Navy to drive a submarine. The most closely accurate depiction of futuristic fighter pilots was in the Wing Commander games. Since the second closest was Space Above and Beyond and as already mentioned they too lost realism for having their pilots take part of ground battles as regular infantry troops. There is no realism to the portrayal of all Earth Force soldiers to know how to fly any kind of ship, unless it is specifically called upon by their duties. The military doesn't work that way and probably never will. But as I said its just a show so I leave it at that.

__________________
One last stand to hold the line against the night...EA President

Posted by Edwin on 11-22-2001 04:55 PM:

It would make sense that the command staff of Babylon 5 be trained as fighter pilots. As they are all stuck in space. If something happend they may need all hands to fight.

__________________
"If you go to Z'ha'dum you will die"
-Kosh
(natives of Z'ha'dum may ignore this)

For all the rest of you.... don't come here.

Posted by Xaphod_x on 11-22-2001 09:49 PM:

It was mentioned that it makes sense for a carrier pilot to be able to fly a starfury.. well just about every EA warship is actually a carrier. That could explain some things.

__________________
Forgive my stupidity.
---
The Fish Institution
http://www.fishinstitution.com

Posted by Fuzzy Modem on 11-22-2001 10:10 PM:

I love WC. Chris Roberts rocks. The movie was awsome too, despite Freddie Prince Jr. Anyone else looking forward to freelancer?

Posted by Coal on 11-23-2001 04:05 AM:

The WC movie is ok, but with all the changes they made from the game, it could have been a completely different story. They already had a whole fleet of ships, a good history, aliens, but they go and create a totally new everything instead of using the one that was proven to work.

Posted by aldo_14 on 11-23-2001 05:54 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by Coal
The WC movie is ok, but with all the changes they made from the game, it could have been a completely different story. They already had a whole fleet of ships, a good history, aliens, but they go and create a totally new everything instead of using the one that was proven to work.

Unless you count Privaterr, i have no idea on the WC storyline....but I thought the movie was ok, not exactly great, but something to watch at 2PM waiting for the footie to come on Sky.

__________________
VBB Survivor - Mar 2001 to 12 April 2002 - 1107 posts

Hit it 'til it gives up....

[URL=http://www.3dap.com/hlp/hosted/reciprocity]RECIPROCITY[/URL] [URL=http://www.3dap.com/hlp/hosted/reciprocity/demo.html]The Luyten Incident[/URL]
[URL=http://www.3dap.com/hlp/hosted/reciprocity/casualtiesofwar/main.htm]Casualties of War[/URL]
ICQ: 119819902

Posted by IceFire on 11-23-2001 07:33 PM:

I thought the movie had a number of merits, overall it was a good fun story, it was a war story, and it drew alot from the spirit of World War 2 combat. Which was kind of neat to have a retro future setup like that.

__________________
- IceFire
Volition Watch Project Manager
[url=http://www.volitionwatch.com]Volition Watch[/url], [url=http://freespace.volitionwatch.com/blackwater]BlackWater Operations[/url], [url=http://freespace.volitionwatch.com/babylon]The Babylon Project[/url], [url=http://terra.sourceforge.net]Machina Terra[/url], [url=http://www.3dap.com/hlp/hosted/ott/]Over The Top[/url]

Posted by Edwin on 11-24-2001 05:20 PM:

is there non-SOD version of WC Privateer?

__________________
"If you go to Z'ha'dum you will die"
-Kosh
(natives of Z'ha'dum may ignore this)

For all the rest of you.... don't come here.

Posted by IceFire on 11-24-2001 06:13 PM:

non-SOD?

Posted by Edwin on 11-25-2001 01:08 AM:

SOD=DOS bacwards. Tht is a description of it's usefulness at this moment.

__________________
"If you go to Z'ha'dum you will die"
-Kosh
(natives of Z'ha'dum may ignore this)

For all the rest of you.... don't come here.

All times are EST. The time now is 07:46 AM.

Show all 20 posts from this thread on one page